Oyatsu Jinja (おやつ神社)

(Snack Shrine)

…a Development Team has been successfully delivering Product Increments at a sustainable pace. Both the team and its technical practices have been improving. Recently, more and more requests are coming into the team asking for help. Members from other teams come asking for technical advice. Managers and other stakeholders frequently come to the team to learn how they work and discuss their new business ideas. Team members often feel interrupted and have less time to concentrate on product development.

✥       ✥       ✥ 

A Development Team needs an environment free from interruptions. At the same time, the team members need to interact with one another and the Product Owner. Additionally, the team needs to interact with people outside the team, like stakeholders and other teams, to continuously improve and share information.

Having the team isolated can impede communication, whereas making the environment fully open to visitors can damage the team’s effectiveness. [1]

Therefore:

Create an Oyatsu Jinja (Snack Shrine) near the team area, with some candies, snacks and drinks (coffee or tea). The shrine needs to be located far enough from the team’s work area so that chatting at the shrine does not disturb the team. However, the shrine needs to be close enough to the team so that people at the shrine and in the team area can recognize one another. Oyatsu Jinja is not a secret place as activities at the shrine need to be observable by the team. It is important that people using the shrine do not interrupt the team.

From A Place to Wait. in [2].

Team members can visit the shrine to take breaks. Snacks help people to relax and give people an opportunity to interact. The shrine creates a place for team members to chat and get help without disturbing the rest of the team.

Stakeholders can visit the shrine. Rather than directly going to the team and interrupting them, they meet team members at the shrine. In many cases, chatting at the shrine is good enough. If the visitors need help from a team member not at the shrine, they will wait for them at the shrine until the team member takes a break. If the team members see the visitors at the shrine, they can adjust when to take a break. If the Development Team is concentrating and no team member is at the shrine, the visitor will notice this and come back to the shrine again sometime later.

Oyatsu Jinja also works as a good communication place after Scrum events. For example, after finishing a Daily Scrum, Sprint Review, and/or Sprint Retrospective, members can use the shrine for quick unofficial follow-up chatting, if necessary.

The shrine can also be an experimental place for kaizen and self-organization. Anyone is welcome to contribute some snacks to the shrine and to help keep the shrine a clean and nice place to meet. For example, some teams develop their own process to keep the coffee fresh. This shrine becomes a locus for self-organization.

Oyatsu Jinja can also work in multiple-team environments. A single shrine can work like a town square for the teams. In this case it is important to locate the shrine in a place easily accessible and visible to the teams.

✥       ✥       ✥ 

This pattern relates to the Water Cooler pattern as it is a common area people can go to chat. Oyatsu Jinja differs from the Water Cooler in the sense that it is highly visible and located close enough to the team so as to facilitate a sustainable communication environment (or ba (場)).

This pattern is also related to the Do Food pattern in [3]. There is something social about breaking bread that can lower barriers and encourage good communication.

There are similarities in this pattern with the Gatekeeper pattern. In this pattern the gatekeeper is the Oyatsu Jinja rather than an individual.

A team can be motivated to defend their own focus if they believe in themselves and in their product; see Product Pride.

The sketch as shown in the solution is inspired by the pattern A Place to Wait from Christopher Alexander that “creates a situation which makes the waiting positive.” [2]


[1] Deborah Ancona and Henrick Bresman. X-teams: How to Build Teams that Lead, Innovate and Succeed. Boston: Harvard Business School Publishing, 2007.

[2] Christopher Alexander, Sarah Ishikawa and Murray Silverstein with Max Jacobson, Ingrid Fiksdahl-King and Shlomo Angel. “A Place to Wait.” In A Pattern Language. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 1977, pattern 150.

[3] Linda Rising and Mary Lynn Manns. “Do Food.” In Fearless Change. Boston: Pearson Education, 2005, Part 3.


Picture from: The Scrum Patterns Group (James Coplien).